Tuesday, 3 January 2012

Invitation - write papers, articles or blog posts with me

About once every 2 or 3 months I get what seems to be a serious approach by someone to do some collaboration with. That collaboration is usually simple enough, perhaps writing a paper or a series of blog posts together. It may be simple enough but it’s a great thing to do. I love the idea of collaborating on the research, writing, review and publication of papers with other test professionals.

But… no one and I mean NO ONE every properly follows up with their offer. There’s some initial discussion, a bouncing back and forth of ideas and then tumble-weed. I can only harass so many times. OK, I’ll cut Kashif and Zaman some slack here as discussions are technically ‘on-going’.

I do understand, there are a few reasons I can think of why papers and articles don’t get written.

Fear of scrutiny (looking stoopid)
I suspect the biggest reason people don’t write articles, papers or blog posts is the fear of peer review, critical peer review and response more importantly. We all suffer this worry, less as we get older and more gnarly sure, but it’s always still there. Let me tell you, first off don’t worry about those who would try and put your work down, secondly look for the criticism.

Do it for two reasons, one is it helps you grow as people question your thinking and understanding and you need to respond, the other is any morons trying to look smart by making smart comments soon show themselves to be the morons they are. It’s a win win for you. So get writing.

Your opinion doesn’t matter, it’s already been said.
Sure, a quick search return 100s of articles on metrics, agile, test management, tools, writing bugs, creating test data, so why bother writing yet another? Heck one you write will be less insightful and badly researched right? Well, maybe but there’s a special something that only you can bring, your unique experiences. Only you can share the from-the-wild stories you’ve experienced and the best way to write is often to tell stories and share what you learned.

What’s more there’s always a need for a new perspective on an already discussed topic. If not then websites, blogs, book publishing and YouTube would grind to a near halt. It’s never been said quite in the way you will. So get writing.

You have a topic but don’t have the answers.

I once wrote a paper called ‘Assessing the Developer / Tester Ratio’, addressing that old question. It was 10 pages of working through models based on measuring development and testing factors, project management theory of constraints, then combining them into a simple and complex model. All with the intent of assessing the required number of testers to developers. I even wrote a html/JavaScript page to do the calculations. It was awesome to the power of geek. It was also completely impractical and the end result was a recommendation the reader would better spend their time just agreeing a ratio (e.g. 4 to 1) and seeing how it worked out for them.

Was it pointless writing it and spending the time doing the research? Absolutely not, contrary to common belief you DO NOT have to have all the answers. Even a PhD thesis leaves questions unanswered. Why not research and write as far as you can and then leave it to the test community to pick up? Perfectly acceptable approach, not one expects you to be a know-it-all, so get writing.

Unt Zo… to zee challenge!
I’d like to invite anyone in the test community to collaborate on writing a paper, article or blog post.

• We’ll split the year into two month slots starting in January. So that would be Jan-Feb, Mar-Apr, May-Jun, etc. Pick a slot that works for you and we’ll get onto it.
• You can pick the topic or we’ll think of one together.
• That catch is – it needs to be a 50/50 effort, more on your side is better!

How hard can it be? What have you got to lose? Etc, etc,… :)



Phil said...

Let me get my move to the US sorted out and then I'll take you up on that - so reserve a spot for me later in the year :)

Shey said...

I guess I am on your tumble weed list. :-)

I have not moved away from my original idea, but I
haven't had the time
have not put the idea high enough on the list.

So, what I need to do is revisit my idea and follow up with you. This will be in January, for sure.

As for collaboration on articles, blog posts, etc., I think this is a good idea. I cannot promise a follow up on this, but I will get a couple of ideas together.

Anonymous said...

I'm sure I replied on the STC and on here, so it may be awaiting moderation, but just in case I forgot to reply on here. I would be happy to get together and brainstorm about writing a paper or article.

Do you have any ideas. I'm thinking more about the soft skill side of testing maybe.

I had an idea after watching Sherlock - Police skills vs tester skills. How to develop them. I am planning to research how the police train their recruits to communicate with people, how to look at evidence and facts and deduce what is happening in their investigation. Skills that as testers we need.


Unknown said...

I'm in for November/December.